CO129-078 - Sir Robinson - 1860 [7-12] — Page 291

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

circumstance mentioned by me solely to show, that until the man made his appearance on board the Elbe, no forcible means were employed to secure his person, and therefore British Laws were not infringed against, but not as you seem to interpret the sentence with a view to lend additional weight to my argument. It was sufficient for my purposes to prove that the man acted on his own impulses and was free from restraint while under the sole control and protection of British Authority - until the moment he set his foot on board the Elbe, where such protection accessorily at once ceased, because there Prussian Authority commenced and this cancelled the pretended rights of third parties. Beyond this I had no interest in the question whether or not the man acted of his own free accord, as it could in nowise affect the bearing of the case.

I am far from underrating the alarming Consequences which would result from a state of things such as you describe, where any sailor, having a grievance against his ship, could with impunity avail himself of the opportunity to desert, and I fully concur with you that if such a state of things was permitted to exist, it would be utterly impossible to preserve law and order amongst the numerous Mercantile Marine frequenting this port.

Edit History

2026-05-18 19:14:25 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
circumstance mentioned by me solely to show, that until the man made his appearance on board the Elbe, no forcible means were employed to secure his person, and therefore British Laws were not infringed against, but not as you seem to interpret the sentence with a view to lend additional weight to my argument. It was sufficient for my purposes to prove that the man acted on his own impulses and was free from restraint while under the sole control and protection of British Authority - until the moment he set his foot on board the Elbe, where such protection accessorily at once ceased, because there Prussian Authority commenced and this cancelled the pretended rights of third parties. Beyond this I had no interest in the question whether or not the man acted of his own free accord, as it could in nowise affect the bearing of the case. I am far from underrating the alarming Consequences which would result from a state of things such as you describe, where any sailor, having a grievance against his ship, could with impunity avail himself of the opportunity to desert, and I fully concur with you that if such a state of things was permitted to exist, it would be utterly impossible to preserve law and order amongst the numerous Mercantile Marine frequenting this port.
Baseline (Original)
8. circumstance mentioned by me solely to show, that until the man made ence on board the Elbe his appearance no forcible means were employed to ana therefore British secure his person, Laws not infringed against, but not as you seems to interpret the sentence with a view to lend additional weight to my -argarment. It was _ s. sufficient for my purposes to prove that the man acted on his Our impulses ana. - free from on restraint while under the sole central on and protection of British Authority- until the moment, be set his foot board the Elbe where such protection. Accessarily at once ceaser, because there Prussian Authority Commenced 286 and this cancelled the pretendes rights of third parties. Beyond this I hon no interest in the question whether or not the man acted of his own free accord, as it coned in nowise affect the bearing of the case. I am for from underrating the alarming Consequences which result & from a world. a state of things such as you describe, where any sailor, having a grievance his ship coned with impunity avail against himself of the opportumly to desert, and I fully Concur with with you that if such a state of things was permitted to exist, it wooned be utterly impossible to preserve law and order Amongst the numerous Mercantile Marine frequenting this port .
2026-05-18 19:14:25 · Baseline
View content

8.

circumstance mentioned by

me solely

to show, that until the man made

ence on board the Elbe

his appearance

no forcible

means were

employed to

ana

therefore British

secure his person,

Laws not infringed against, but

not as

you

seems to interpret the sentence

with a view to lend additional weight

to

my

-argarment. It was

_

s.

sufficient

for my purposes to prove that the man

acted on his

Our

impulses

ana.

- free from

on

restraint while under the sole central

on

and protection of British Authority- until the moment, be set his foot board the Elbe where such protection. Accessarily at once ceaser, because there Prussian Authority Commenced

286

and this cancelled the pretendes rights of third parties. Beyond this I hon no interest in the question whether or not the man acted of his own free accord, as it coned in nowise affect the bearing

of the case.

I am for from

underrating the

alarming Consequences

which

result

& from a

world.

a state of things such as you

describe, where any sailor, having a grievance his ship coned with impunity avail

against

himself of the opportumly to desert, and I

fully

Concur with

with you that if such a

state of things was permitted to exist, it wooned be utterly impossible to preserve

law

and order Amongst the numerous Mercantile Marine frequenting this port .

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.